Etsy vs Shopify – Which Ecommerce Platform to Choose?

Etsy vs Shopify

When it comes to starting an online business, choosing the right platform is crucial. With so many e-commerce options available, Etsy and Shopify stand out as two of the most popular choices and each has its own advantages and drawbacks. 

Etsy is a marketplace designed specifically for handmade, vintage, and unique items, whereas shopify is a fully customizable ecommerce platform that allows businesses to build their own online store, providing greater control over branding.

What is Etsy?

Etsy is an online marketplace that specializes in handmade, vintage, and unique goods. Sellers list their products on Etsy’s platform, competing with others in the same niche. It is a go-to platform for independent artists, crafters, and small business owners who want to sell their creative products to a global audience without the need for a dedicated website.

The platform takes care of aspects like payment processing, customer interactions, and marketing to some extent, making it a convenient option for sellers who want a simple setup without dealing with technical aspects of running a website.

Key Features of Etsy

• Built-in marketplace with millions of active buyers
• Focus on handmade, vintage, and creative goods
• SEO benefits from Etsy’s internal search engine
• Limited customization and branding options

What is Shopify?

Shopify is an e-commerce platform that allows sellers to create their own independent online store with full customization. Unlike Etsy, Shopify provides sellers with a standalone website where they have complete control over their store’s branding, pricing, and customer experience. It is a scalable platform that supports businesses of all sizes, from startups to large enterprises. If you’re new to Shopify, check out our guide on how Shopify works to understand its features and benefits in detail.

Key Features of Shopify

• Full control over branding and store design
• No direct competition on your store’s website
• Advanced e-commerce tools (analytics, inventory management, integrations)
• Requires self-driven marketing to attract buyers.

Comparing Etsy and Shopify

Etsy is known for being user-friendly, especially for beginners or casual sellers. The platform does most of the heavy lifting when it comes to store management, making it ideal for those who want to start selling quickly without much technical knowledge.

Shopify, on the other hand, is designed for more serious entrepreneurs looking for a custom, scalable solution. It requires more effort to set up and manage, but it gives you more flexibility and control over the look, feel, and functionality of your store.

Etsy vs. Shopify Pricing Comparison

Etsy: Pricing Plan

Etsy does not charge a monthly subscription fee, making it more accessible in terms of initial costs but charges a 5% transaction fee on every sale, plus payment processing fees, which can vary depending on the country. Additionally, sellers must pay $0.20 per listing, which is non-refundable even if the listing doesn’t sell.

Shopify: Pricing Plan

With monthly plans starting from $39 per month (for the Basic plan), and charges transaction fees, but you can avoid these fees if you use Shopify Payments as your payment gateway to reduce additional fees. Shopify’s 14-day free trial allows you to test the features before committing to a subscription plan.

Etsy vs Shopify Comparison

Features  of Etsy 

Product Types

Etsy specializes in selling handmade, vintage, and craft supplies. It is particularly suitable for small businesses, artisans, and crafters who want to sell custom-made products, such as jewelry, clothing, home decor, art, and accessories. Sellers cannot list mass-produced items or products that don’t fit into the handmade or vintage categories.

Ease of Use

Setting up an Etsy store is quick and user-friendly as it handles the technical side of things, including hosting and security. Listing products is straightforward, and it provides a range of tools to help you manage your shop, and track orders. This simplicity makes it an ideal platform for beginner sellers who want to start quickly.

Customization

Sellers can adjust their shop appearance by uploading a shop banner, logo, and changing the shop description, but the design options are constrained to the predefined templates Etsy offers. While it’s great for simple, easy-to-manage stores, Etsy’s design options may feel restrictive for those who want more control over the aesthetic of their shop.

Mobile Optimization

Etsy’s mobile app is well-suited for both buyers and sellers. Sellers can use the Etsy Seller app to manage their shops, check order statuses, respond to customer inquiries, and update product listings. The mobile app is simple and easy to use, but it may not be ideal for complex store management.

Inventory Management

Etsy offers a basic inventory management system that works for small businesses. Sellers can manually update the stock of each product, and Etsy will send notifications when stock is low. However, Etsy does not provide advanced features such as bulk inventory updates, multi-location management, or automated stock control. 

Marketing Tools

Sellers can run Etsy Ads, which allow their listings to be promoted within the platform, appearing in search results. Sellers can share their products on social media platforms which can help attract external traffic. However, Etsy’s marketing tools are relatively basic compared to other platforms, and sellers may find them somewhat limiting as they grow.

Customer Support

Etsy offers a help center and community forums where sellers can find answers to common questions and exchange tips with other shop owners. Etsy also provides email support for more specific issues, and sellers can contact support directly for assistance with any problems that arise. 

Payment Processing

Etsy uses Etsy Payments, which consolidates all payment options like credit cards, PayPal, Apple Pay, and Google Pay. This centralized payment system simplifies transactions for sellers and buyers alike. However, Etsy charges a fee for payment processing (typically 3% + $0.25 per transaction), and sellers have limited flexibility in choosing their payment method.

Transaction Fees

Etsy charges a 5% transaction fee for each sale, which is applied to the total sale price. Additionally, Etsy charges a payment processing fee which depends on the country and the payment method used. For example, for U.S. sellers, this is typically around 3% + $0.25 per transaction.

Features of Shopify

Product Types

Shopify allows you to sell any type of product, including physical goods, digital products, services, and subscriptions. Whether you’re selling clothing, electronics, ebooks, software, or even offering a subscription box, Shopify accommodates virtually any type of business.

Ease of Use

Setting up a Shopify store is also straightforward, but it involves more steps than Etsy. You need to choose a pricing plan, pick a theme, customize your store’s layout, and set up essential features such as payment gateways, taxes, and shipping options. Shopify is still user-friendly, with drag-and-drop tools to customize your store, and it provides extensive tutorials and customer support to help you. 

Customization

Shopify offers a variety of themes, and you can modify these themes using the built-in drag-and-drop editor. For users with coding experience, Shopify gives you full access to the HTML, CSS, and Liquid code, enabling you to tweak every detail of your store’s design. You can also install apps to extend the store’s functionality, such as adding customer reviews, or advanced product filters.

Mobile Optimization

The platform automatically adjusts your store layout to fit mobile screens, ensuring that customers can easily browse and shop from their smartphones and tablets. Store owners can process orders, track inventory, manage customers, and fulfill orders from their mobile devices. This level of mobile optimization is highly beneficial for entrepreneurs who need flexibility and want to manage their store.

Inventory Management

Shopify’s inventory tools allow you to track stock levels in real-time, set up low-stock alerts, and update your inventory across multiple locations. Shopify also integrates with third-party fulfillment services and dropshipping providers, allowing you to automate much of your inventory management. This makes Shopify perfect for detailed and efficient inventory management tools.

Marketing Tools

Shopify is built with SEO features, allowing sellers to optimize their store with customizable meta tags, titles, descriptions, and URLs for each product. Shopify also provides built-in email marketing tools that let sellers design and send campaigns directly to customers. Shopify supports the creation of discount codes, helping sellers promote their store and attract customers.

Customer Support

Shopify provides 24/7 customer support across multiple channels and ensures that sellers can get assistance with issues at any time. Shopify also has an extensive Help Center for solving common issues. Shopify’s customer support is comprehensive, timely, and personalized, making it suitable for businesses that require more hands-on assistance.

Payment Processing

Shopify has a built-in payment processing system called Shopify Payments, which supports credit cards, PayPal, Apple Pay, and Google Pay. Shopify Payments helps reduce transaction fees, offering a more affordable option for sellers who use the system. However, if sellers opt to use third-party payment gateways, Shopify imposes additional fees (from 2% to 0.5%, depending on the plan). 

Transaction Fees

Shopify charges transaction fees based on the plan selected by the seller. For example, the Basic Shopify plan charges 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction, while the Shopify plan charges 2.6% + 30¢, and the Advanced Shopify plan charges 2.4% + 30¢. These fees can be reduced if sellers use Shopify Payments instead of third-party payment processors, which is a major advantage for those who want to avoid extra fees.

Pros and Cons of Etsy

Pros of Selling on Etsy

• Built-in audience with millions of buyers
• Easy to set up and start selling low upfront costs
• Marketing and SEO benefits from Etsy’s search engine

Cons of Selling on Etsy

• High competition with other sellers
• Listing and transaction fees
• Limited customization and branding

Pros and Cons of Shopify

Pros of Selling on Shopify

• Full control over branding and store design.
• No direct competition on your store’s website.
• Flexible pricing plans.
• Advanced e-commerce tools (analytics, inventory management, integrations).

Cons of Selling on Shopify

•  Requires more effort to drive traffic.
•  Monthly subscription fees.
• More responsibility for marketing and SEO.

Who Should Use Etsy?

Etsy is the perfect platform for creators, artisans, and small businesses that specialize in unique, handmade, vintage, or craft-based products. It provides an easy and affordable way to showcase and sell your work to a wide audience. Etsy is particularly beneficial for hobbyists or those looking to test the waters of e-commerce without committing to a significant upfront cost. Its low listing fees and simple setup process make it ideal for individual sellers or small-scale businesses that don’t have the resources to build or maintain their own website. 

Who Should Use Shopify?

Shopify is best suited for established businesses or entrepreneurs who want more control over their online store and are looking to scale. If you have a growing business that sells a wide range of products and you need advanced features like detailed analytics, robust marketing tools, custom design options, and integrated shipping solutions, Shopify is the platform to consider. Shopify provides the flexibility to sell across multiple channels, from your own branded online store to marketplaces, social media platforms, and physical retail locations.

Final Comparison: Which One Should You Choose?

• Choose Etsy if: You sell handmade or vintage items and want to tap into an existing audience without much marketing effort.
• Choose Shopify if: You want to build your own brand, have full control over your store, and scale your business over time.
• Use both if: You want the best of both worlds—Etsy for initial exposure and Shopify for long-term growth.

Conclusion

If you’re just starting, Etsy is an excellent place to test the market. However, for long-term growth and brand independence, Shopify is the better investment. Some successful entrepreneurs even use both platforms—starting on Etsy and later transitioning to Shopify for more control.

Ultimately, the choice between Etsy and Shopify comes down to the specific needs, goals, and resources of the seller. Etsy is the ideal platform for those who focus on handmade, vintage, or artisanal products. For individuals or small businesses just getting started, Etsy’s low-cost and user-friendly environment offers a chance to test the waters without having to invest in a custom-built website or complicated logistics. 

On the other hand, Shopify is tailored for sellers who want to build a professional, scalable business with more flexibility and control. For entrepreneurs and established businesses looking to grow beyond a niche market, Shopify offers a wide array of features that empower users to fully customize their store, integrate various sales channels, and access in-depth data analytics.

FAQs